4.2

Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars

5 Customer Reviews

Customers Say

These aluminum sheet pans are appreciated for their versatility and durability, suitable for various baking and cooking needs. Customers find them sturdy and easy to clean, fitting well in both home and commercial ovens. They are also noted for their ability to withstand high temperatures without warping. Opinions on quality vary, with some users noting occasional dents or scratches upon delivery.

  • pan
  • sheet
  • bake
  • cookies
  • cover
  • covers
  • easily
  • half
  • size
  • 2023

This AI-generated summary was created from real customer reviews

Showing 5 of 5 reviews
Review by

Denise L. from The Stacked Cookie

Posted on 02/15/2023

Verified Purchase

Rated 1 out of 5 stars
Size:
Half Size
Feature:
With Cover

I have purchased these many times. And each subsequent time, they quality has gotten worse. The latest version (purchased in 2023) use two small easily breakable tabs to latch onto the rolled edge of a sheet pan. These new ones don't hold onto anything. They pop right off. I'm not sure if the pictures or video came through as I write this because when I go to check on them the form is clear.

Thank you for your review, Denise! We’re sorry to hear you had problems with this product and will remain in contact with you to remedy it. We have also taken this feedback to the manufacturer to ensure the problem is fixed moving forward!

Review by

Kimberly B. from Kimberly’S Cookies

Posted on 02/26/2022

Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Size:
Half Size
Feature:
With Cover

I absolutely love my half sheet pan covers!! They’re amazing for covering your decorated sugar cookies before packaging! They’re super well made, durable to uphold their use!

Review by

Paul T.

Posted on 06/29/2025

Verified Purchase

Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Size:
Half Size
Feature:
With Cover

I recently used the Choice Half Size 19 Gauge 13" x 18" Wire in Rim Aluminum Sheet Pan with Cover to bake cookies, and it’s a fantastic kitchen tool.

Review by

Patricia R.

Posted on 04/18/2025

Verified Purchase

Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Size:
Quarter Size
Feature:
With Cover

I like to bake slab pies and this is the perfect size. Very happy with the durability and the thickness of the metal pan.

Review by

Susan C.

Posted on 11/28/2022

Verified Purchase

Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Size:
Full Size
Feature:
With Cover

I have 6 of these and they're very easy to use. Cover goes on and off and the pan slides into the pan rack easily.